Management theory is becoming a compendium of dead ideas
What Martin Luther did to the Catholic church needs to be done to business gurus
NEXT year marks the 500th anniversary of the event which, more than any other, gave birth to the modern world: Martin Luther promulgated his 95 theses and called the Catholic church to account for its numerous theological errors and institutional sins. Revisionist historians have inevitably complicated the story (including questioning whether he did actually nail his proposals to the door of All Saints’ Church in Wittenberg) but the narrative remains clear. The church was ripe for change. It was sunk in corruption and divorced from the wider life of society. And by unleashing that change, Luther brought the Christian faith, including Roman Catholicism itself, a new lease of life.
The similarities between medieval Christianity and the world of management theory may not be obvious, but seek and ye shall find. Management theorists sanctify capitalism in much the same way that clergymen of yore sanctified feudalism. Business schools are the cathedrals of capitalism. Consultants are its travelling friars. Just as the clergy in the Middle Ages spoke in Latin to give their words an air of authority, management theorists speak in mumbo-jumbo. The medieval clergy’s sale of indulgences, by which believers could effectively buy forgiveness of their sins, is echoed by management theorists selling fads that will solve all your business problems. Lately, another similarity has emerged. The gurus have lost touch with the world they seek to rule. Management theory is ripe for a Reformation of its own.
This article appeared in the Business section of the print edition under the headline "Out with the old"
Business December 17th 2016
- What DeepMind brings to Alphabet
- Alphabet’s Google is searching for its next hit
- Behind the bid for Sky is a less powerful Murdoch empire
- France’s corporate raider, Vincent Bolloré, makes a bid for Italy’s biggest broadcaster
- Food packaging is not the enemy of the environment that it is assumed to be
- In Germany mature workers are answering to young supervisors
- The management style of Amancio Ortega
- Management theory is becoming a compendium of dead ideas
More from Business
Big tech’s great AI power grab
Alphabet, Amazon and Microsoft are on the hunt for new energy sources
Does Perplexity’s “answer engine” threaten Google?
Taking aim at one of the best business models of all times
How not to work on a plane
Hours without interruption and work to do. What could go wrong?